Film

No.	Year	Title	Role	Vote Average
1	1997	Pleasant Grove	Bedford	44
2	1998	Physical Pinball	Guy playing pool	52
3	2000	George Washington	Rico Rice	67
4	2001	Security, Colorado	Paul	0
5	2003	All the Real Girls	Paul	59
6	2004	50 Ways to Leave Your Lover	Owen McCabe	42
7	2005	Elizabethtown	Jessie Baylor	62
8	2005	The Family Stone	Brad Stevenson	63
9	2006	Live Free or Die	Lagrand	52
10	2007	The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford	Dick Liddil	70
11	2007	Lars and the Real Girl	Gus	72
12	2009	Away We Go	Courtney	67
13	2009	Bright Star	Mr. Brown	66
14	2011	Water for Elephants	Charlie	69
15	2011	Beloved	Henderson	62
16	2011	The Flowers of War	Terry	74
17	2012	The Babymakers	Tommy Macklin	51
18	2013	Hello Carter	Aaron	59
19	2014	Black Eyed Dog		0
20	2014	Goodbye to All That	Otto Wall	48
21	2015	The Daughter	Christian	64
22	2016	Café Society	Steve	65
23	2016	Rules Don't Apply	Richard Miskin	57
24	2020	Brothers by Blood	Jimmy	58
25	2021	A House on the Bayou	John Chambers	57
26	2022	Abandoned	Dr. Carver	59
27	2022	American Murderer	David Brown	59
28	2025	Xeno	Chase	0

Television

No.	Year	Title	Role	Vote Average
1	1990	Law & Order	Daniel Strawn	74
2	1999	Third Watch	Warner	79
3	2009	Parks and Recreation	Mark Brendanawicz	80
4	2012	The Newsroom	Brian Brenner	81
5	2014	The Divide	Clark Rylance	65
6	2016	American Crime Story	Paul Beck	76
7	2016	Channel Zero	Mike Painter	71
8	2016	Chance	Ryan Winter	69
9	2019	NOS4A2	Jonathan 'The Hourglass' Beckett	73
10	2019	The Righteous Gemstones		74
11	2020	Tales from the Loop	George	70
12	2022	A Friend of the Family	Marty	67
13	2023	Florida Man	Andy Boone	67